The Cottage Inn in New York

"I love this place! Food was amazing. Had one waitress on and the place was busy. She kept up. I dont know how, but she got an extra tip. Please get that girl help."

"Our family visited The Cottage Inn on Saturday, February 4th and although there was a short wait time, the food was WELL WORTH IT!! The mac n cheese topped with pulled pork was absolutely delicious, their poutine was just as good as what I've had from The Upstate Tavern and their wings...EXCEPTIONALLY PERFECT with just the right amount of crispness and sauce!! I'm looking forward to another visit soon!!!"

"Although my wife's meal was awesome, mine was not so. The pull pork was over cooked to the point of being burnt and just a single layer on top of a huge bun. Was not impressed, however the sweet potato fries were excellent. Staff very friendly and attentive for such a small restaurant. Would consider going again, but next time I will say something about my meal if it comes out the way it did the first time."

"My husband & I stopped for lunch on our way back home. We had been wanting to stop for a long while but never made the time. Service was excellent. Food was delicious."

"Driving through and saw sign for taco Tuesday without knowing anything about this place. Decided to give try and was excellent decision. The inside is big and clean with a nice bar and tables. And there's also a dining room with tvs for games. Prices are fair. Tacos were excellent. Prime rib soup excellent. Also friendly service. Definitely worth a repeat visit."

"The Cottage Inn is a welcoming lunch and dinner destination that delivers a satisfying dining experience. From the moment you step inside, the inviting ambiance and warm hospitality set the tone for a pleasant visit. The service is commendable, with friendly and attentive staff who enhance the overall experience. While the bar area is small, it exudes charm, making it a great spot to unwind. The dining area accommodates both small and larger groups comfortably, making it a versatile choice for various occasions. That said, diners should anticipate a wait for their meals. As the restaurant fills up, the kitchen struggles to keep pace, leading to wait times that can extend beyond 40 minutes. While this may be a drawback for some, the food’s quality upon arrival largely compensates for the delay. The menu offers a solid selection of options, catering to different tastes. One standout was the build-your-own burger, featuring double half-pound patties topped with bacon, cheese, jalapeños, lettuce, and tomato, served with crispy fries and a side of nacho cheese. Despite the extended wait, the meal arrived fresh, hot, and visually appealing. The bacon was flavorful, though not particularly crispy, while the cheese was perfectly melted. The tomato slices were on the larger side, making the burger slightly challenging to eat, but the fresh lettuce and well-toasted bun added to its appeal. With the generous toppings, the burger was a bit messy, requiring a knife to cut, but it was cooked to a perfect medium-well as requested, with a rich and satisfying flavor. The fries were well-seasoned with a slight coating for extra crispness, pairing well with the nacho cheese. To accompany the meal, the iced tea with pomegranate flavoring was an excellent choice—refreshing and well-balanced. With over five flavors available to customize drinks, the beverage selection adds an extra layer of variety. The bar is well-stocked with both beer liquor and wine, and even during a busy service, the bartender/server maintained a friendly and efficient presence. Overall, The Cottage Inn offers a solid dining experience with well-executed food and a welcoming atmosphere. While the wait for food can be lengthy during peak hours, the quality and portion sizes make it worth the visit. Whether stopping in for lunch or dinner, guests can enjoy a well-rounded menu with enticing specials and drinks. The winter season draws in snowmobile traffic, keeping the restaurant lively, but it remains a worthwhile stop for those seeking good food and a relaxed environment. Looking forward to a return visit to explore more of the menu."

"Awesome food and atmosphere. Must stop for a blue light, some curds with both sauces and wings. Everything was fantastic"

"I ordered the cottage corned beef and it was the biggest and best Reuben I have ever had. There had to be at least a pound of corned beef in the sandwich and if I had to guess the bread was cut length ways from a small loaf. Just huge and thick slices of perfectly toasted rye. It had the perfect ratio of ingredients. I highly recommend eating at the cottage inn. Absolutely AMAZING !"